Take The Puffy Mattress Quiz
What is your ideal price range?
Who do you share your bed space with?
What build are you?
Do you experience sleeping hot?
What's your comfort preference?
Calculating result...
Arrow left Back ×
Your Puffy Cart 0 Items
Cart is empty
Free shipping and returns

Puffy Mattress Comparison

There are many different brands of online mattresses you can choose from when you decide it’s time for a new mattress. Whether you're replacing your old mattress or you’re setting up your first home, choosing a new mattress is a big decision. At Puffy Mattress, it is our goal to make your mattress buying decision as easy as possible by offering you a top-rated mattress created with the highest quality materials. The journey to create the puffy mattress was filled with many years of testing and retesting to ensure that we had created the perfect mattress for all types of sleepers.

Years ago, one of the founders of Puffy mattress was flying home after a business trip. Like most travelers, he spent some time looking out the window at the brilliant visual display of clouds you see at that altitude. And then the thought hit him – “What would it be like to lay on a cloud?” When he returned home, he couldn’t get that thought of laying on a cloud out of his mind.

That experience became the impetus for the Puffy founders to begin researching how to create a perfectly comfortable mattress. Their goal was to create a mattress that felt like a cloud to sleep on. And thus began their mission of creating the most comfortable mattress you can buy.

It did not happen at once of course. One does not just invent the perfect mattress overnight. The Puffy research team evaluated a variety of mattress foam materials. They experimented with different layers until they found the perfect combination of materials. They thought long and hard about what was the perfect formula.

Ultimately, they created a mattress that is highly adaptive, that supports your body and adjusts to you so all your pressure points and aches are relieved.

But here are some other great things to know about the way we made Puffy mattresses.

  • Our mattresses are manufactured responsibly. We make our mattresses right here in the Canada using CertiPUR-US® certified foam. Nothing in our mattresses will deplete the ozone. They do not contain any PBDEs. There is no formaldehyde, no mercury, no lead or other heavy metals and our mattresses have very low VOC (volatile organic compound) emissions.
  • You will get the best sleep you’ve had in years, guaranteed. We are so confident that we're willing to put our money where our mouth is. If you purchase a mattress from our website, you can try our mattress for 101 nights. If you don’t find that you're getting great sleep, you can send it back. Most mattresses take a month or two before they adjust to your body, but if after that time you’re still not satisfied, send the mattress back.
  • We also offer a limited lifetime warranty. This is one of the best warranties you’ll find anywhere online when you’re shopping for a mattress. If any manufacturing defects emerge over the first 10 years that you own a Puffy mattress, we will either fix the defects or send you a brand-new mattress free of charge. And you still get to keep the old mattress.

Yet fabulous warrantees aren’t the reason why you should buy a Puffy mattress. It will honestly be the best mattress you've ever slept on. You’ll find comfort that you didn’t think was possible from a mattress bought online.

How Do Puffy Mattresses Stack up Against the Competition?

As we noted above when you shop for online mattresses you have many different brands to choose from. Which one is the best? Many of our competitors produce fine products, but we believe the Puffy mattress is the best choice you can make.

Casper mattress versus Puffy mattress

No doubt you’ve heard of the Casper mattress if you’ve ever listened to an online program or a podcast. Casper advertises widely and makes a real effort at letting people know about its mattress. But how does it stack up against the Puffy mattress?
Perhaps the biggest difference is that Puffy mattresses are made to order. We don’t start making your new mattress for you until you ask for it. So that means it spends less time in a box and there will be a minimal amount of off-gassing. The Puffy mattress is a real memory foam mattress and handles the issue of heat distribution better. Our top layer is designed to help spread your body heat out on its surface. The Casper mattress does offer some heat distribution as well, but since it is composed of four different layers, some can retain heat.
While both mattresses retail for around the same price, don’t forget included in the price of a Casper mattress is all that advertising. The price you pay for Puffy mattress is all about comfort and a good night’s sleep.

Tuft & Needle mattress versus Puffy mattress

Tuft & Needle offers one of the more low-priced mattresses in the online space. But it’s aimed more at students and similar shoppers who don’t want to spend a lot of money for a mattress that they may only need for a limited time.
When Tuft & Needle went head-to-head against Puffy mattress in a recent comparison, Puffy emerged as the winner in almost every category including customer satisfaction, price value and back pain (the absence thereof). While the reviewer had positive things to say about both mattresses, the edge definitely went to Puffy.

Purple mattress versus Puffy mattress

The distinctive look of the purple materials used in a Purple mattress might be ideal for someone who daydreams about being a member of royalty one day. But if you’re looking for the most comfortable mattress, you’re probably going to want to choose a Puffy.
Once again, the difference starts here with the fact that your Puffy mattress is not made until you order it. That means it spends less time in a box, takes its intended shape much quicker and off-gases much more easily. And here’s something else that you need to think about if you’ve ever lugged a mattress up four flights of stairs in a building that doesn’t have an elevator. A queen-size Purple mattress weighs about 110 pounds. A queen Puffy mattress tips the scales at about 69 pounds.
A recent review of the two mattresses found the Puffy mattress a more comfortable sleep, with more substantial support and a more consistent feel.

Layla mattress versus Puffy mattress

This is a good mattress, but in a recent head-to-head recent comparison, the Puffy mattress was slightly better in several important categories.
The Puffy mattress achieved better marks in customer satisfaction and price value and scored higher overall with the reviewers. The Layla mattress also tends to sleep a bit hotter than the Puffy mattress. Layla recommends its users leave the temperature in the bedroom at 72 degrees Fahrenheit, but that is not always possible. Both mattresses were given positive remarks by customers who left comments on the reviewer’s website, but Puffy customers were far more enthusiastic about their mattresses and gave many more five out of five-star reviews.

Leesa mattress versus Puffy mattress

The Leesa mattress is another contender in the online mattress arena. But like some of the other mattresses we’ve mentioned, when compared to a Puffy mattress, it’s not quite as good.
Although we’ve already mentioned this in a couple of the above reviews, one of the main differences is that your Puffy mattress is not made until you actually order it. It’s not that automatic assembly line process where you just make a bunch of mattresses and toss them in the back room until somebody orders one. Since our mattresses spend less time wrapped in plastic, off-gassing is kept to a minimum. This is a very good thing if you have small children or adults with breathing problems in your house.
The differences in the top layers used by the Leesa mattress and the Puffy mattress affect motion transfer. When compared side-by-side, the Puffy mattress provides more motion isolation. This means when you get up in the middle of the night to go to get a glass of water, you’re not going to wake up your partner.

Nectar mattress versus Puffy mattress

There are several important differences between a Nectar mattress and Puffy mattress. The number one difference is where they are made. Puffy mattresses are made in Canada. Nectar mattresses are largely made in China. All of the foam used in Puffy mattresses come from Canadian suppliers, a Puffy cloud cover is Canadian-made and our mattresses are assembled and sewn in this country. Important elements of Nectar mattresses like its foam layers and its cover are made in China and the mattress itself is assembled and sewn in China.

Another advantage is that Puffy offers a free lifetime warranty on every single product, including mattresses, bases, and bedding. Nectar offers a similar ‘Forever Warranty,’ but it’s only applicable on mattresses. By contrast, Puffy’s lifetime warranty stipulates that you will be covered for as long as you own any one of our products, no strings attached. 

Canadian value and a risk-free lifetime warranty help lift Puffy mattresses over Nectar mattresses. 

Why You Should Purchase Our Mattress

As you can see from the above comparisons, the Puffy mattress is your best bet in many important categories including value and comfort.

Our advanced design is what makes our mattress so amazing. We use three layers of foam that work together to keep you comfortable and feeling cool throughout the night. Our first layer uses our Cloud Gel to spread the heat from your body across the mattress surface, which helps it dissipate faster. The other benefit of this layer is how it contours gently around your body. This is one of the keys to the pressure relief that so many of our customers love.

In the middle, you have our ClimateComfort™ layer, which incorporates advanced temperature and humidity-resistant materials that adapt to climate fluctuations which can easily ruin a good night's sleep. This material also prevents seasonal expansion and contraction that can occur due to temperature changes, which means you get a consistent mattress feel throughout the year.

Then you have our base layer - the thick support layer. It helps provide support for your spine. It keeps the mattress from sagging because it adjusts to the exact weight of your body. It helps align your back. In fact, many reviewers and customers have said that the Puffy mattress is the perfect mattress for people who sleep on their back or on their sides, which are the vast majority of sleepers. If you like to sleep in your stomach, however, you’ll find that same great support and comfort.

After you spent several nights sleeping on a Puffy mattress, you’ll notice how your energy levels are higher. That’s because you’re getting a better night’s sleep. Our mattress also helps improve your circulation and relieve aching joint pain. You’ll fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer.

Puffy mattresses have a medium firmness. It’s soft but you never feel like you’re trapped the way you do with some foam mattresses where you have to fight a battle every morning just to get out of bed. One reason for that is our foam beds don’t transfer a lot of motion. So if it’s your turn to check on the baby and you do have to get up in the middle of the night, you can get up from our mattress and not wake up your partner. This is also a great feature if your partner moves around a lot at night. Thanks to Puffy’s advanced motion isolation, you’ll hardly even notice it.

Have we convinced you yet?

Well here are a few more reasons to buy a Puffy mattress.

  • Our Quick Sleep option. You can purchase this option as part of your warranty. After 10 years, we will provide you with a new mattress at half the original price you paid 10 years before.
  • If you’re not satisfied with our mattress, we will pick it up and donate it to a local charity. We will also refund all your money. None of our mattresses end up in a landfill but will be given to people who really need them.
  • In a review of the best mattresses available online in 2019, the top two spots were Puffy mattresses — the Puffy lux mattress with a score of 9.8 out of 10 and the Puffy mattress the score of 9.6 out of 10. The results were based on almost 18,500 reviews.

As you can see, we're not the only ones to think that the Puffy mattress is the best online mattress available in Canada. When you want a mattress that delivers comfort, coolness, and relief from the aches and pains of the day, the mattress you want is a Puffy.

How You Can Get a Puffy Mattress

Puffy mattresses come in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King sizes. If you want to spread out the payments, we offer a service through Splitit that lets you pay as little as $62 a month interest-free for 12 months. You can have a Puffy mattress dispatched to your door via FedEx in 1 - 2 business days at no charge. When you’re ready to purchase your Puffy mattress visit our shop page you can select and order your Puffy mattress the way you like it.


  1. https://puffy.ca/pages/puffy-mattress-warranty
  2. https://www.slumbersearch.com/puffy-vs-tuft-and-needle-mattress-reviews
  3. https://oursleepguide.com/casper-vs-puffy-mattress-reviews/
  4. https://oursleepguide.com/purple-vs-puffy-mattress-reviews/
  5. https://oursleepguide.com/leesa-vs-puffy-mattress-review/
  6. https://puffy.ca/pages/puffy-compared-to-nectar
  7. https://puffy.ca/pages/jumpforkids
  8. https://bestmattressonline.org/top102.html
  9. https://puffy.ca/pages/how-its-made
  10. https://puffy.ca/pages/puffy-mattress-sleep-guarantee
  11. https://www.slumbersearch.com/layla-vs-puffy-mattress-reviews